李恒熙 李恒威:二阶意欲与欲望的冲突

作者:发布时间:2010-11-08浏览次数:281

  要: 在《意志的自由与人的概念》这篇文章中,哈里·法兰克福提出了人的本质在于二阶意欲的理论,二阶意欲为我们理解欲望的冲突提供了关键的概念工具。我们运用二阶意欲这一概念表明,欲望的冲突并非是出现在人们心中一阶欲望之间的冲突,而是关于一阶欲望的二阶意欲的冲突。基于这一论断,我们论证,由于误解了欲望冲突的本性,使得法兰克福提出的人的本质在于二阶意欲这一理论所依据的对于不自愿的瘾君子和所谓放浪者的分析是错误的,进一步,法兰克福在深化上述文章所提出的观点时,对涉及欲望冲突的现象做出了错误的描述。

关键词: 二阶意欲; 欲望的冲突; 一阶欲望; 不自愿的瘾君子; 放浪者

 

Second-Order Volition and Conflict between Desires

LI Heng-xi, LI Heng-wei

AbstractIn Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person, Harry Frankfurt put forward a theory that what is essential to being a person is second-order volition. The concept of second-order volition can be used as a key conceptual tool in understanding conflict between different desires. The essence of conflict between desires lies in conflict between second-order volitions, not conflict between first-order desires. Due to misunderstanding the essence, the analysis of unwilling addict and wanton addict that Frankfurt gave is wrong. Furthermore, in his follow-up articles, Frankfurt made wrong description of phenomena involving conflict between desires.

Key words second-order volition; conflict between Desires; first-order desire; unwilling addict; wanton

 

关于本刊

在线阅读

信息公告

关注我们